Steel Shingles vs Asphalt Shingles: Why Asphalt Still Reigns Supreme in 2026
A Classic Roofing Debate
When choosing a new roof, homeowners often face one of the most common dilemmas: steel shingles vs asphalt shingles. Both have their merits — steel roofs are durable and energy-efficient, while asphalt shingles are affordable and versatile.
Yet, despite the growing buzz around metal roofing, asphalt shingles continue to dominate more than 70% of residential roofs in North America. Why? Because they strike the perfect balance between cost, performance, and curb appeal.
If you’re comparing your options, this guide will help you understand the differences and why asphalt shingles may be the smarter choice for most homes.
Understanding the Two Roofing Materials
What Are Asphalt Shingles?
Asphalt shingles are made from a fiberglass base layered with asphalt and mineral granules for waterproofing and UV protection. Available in three-tab, architectural, and designer styles, they’re known for their versatility, ease of installation, and wide range of colors and textures.
They typically last 20–30 years, and with today’s manufacturing advancements, high-quality asphalt shingles can now rival premium materials in durability and style.
What Are Steel Shingles?
Steel shingles, on the other hand, are made from galvanized or galvalume-coated steel panels. They offer excellent longevity and resistance to extreme weather but come at a much higher upfront cost. Steel roofs can last 40–70 years, though their initial price and installation complexity can be a significant barrier for many homeowners.
Appearance and Aesthetics
One of the most appealing features of asphalt shingles is their design flexibility. They come in hundreds of colors and textures, allowing homeowners to match virtually any architectural style — from traditional colonial homes to modern cottages.
While steel shingles are often painted or stone-coated to resemble other materials, they can sometimes appear industrial or metallic, especially as the finish ages. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, maintain their natural, textured look for decades with minimal upkeep.
Installation and Maintenance
Asphalt shingles are easier and faster to install, which reduces labor costs. Their lightweight design and straightforward installation process make them a top choice for both contractors and homeowners.
Steel shingles require specialized tools and experienced contractors, which increases the installation cost. Additionally, repairs can be more complicated — replacing a single damaged steel panel often means removing several surrounding panels.
In contrast, asphalt shingles are simple to repair or replace, keeping maintenance costs low over the lifetime of the roof.
Cost Comparison: Upfront and Long-Term
Here’s where the difference becomes clear.
| Category | Asphalt Shingles | Steel Shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Material Cost (per sq. ft.) | $1.50 – $4.50 | $7.00 – $12.00 |
| Installed Cost (per sq. ft.) | $3.50 – $6.50 | $9.00 – $14.00 |
| Maintenance Cost (Lifetime) | Low | Low–Moderate |
| Expected Lifespan | 20–30 years | 40–70 years |
While steel shingles last longer, the return on investment often doesn’t justify the steep upfront price — especially for homeowners who may sell their property within 15–20 years. Asphalt shingles deliver excellent value for the cost, making them ideal for both first-time buyers and budget-conscious homeowners.
Durability and Weather Resistance
Modern asphalt shingles are far more durable than they used to be. High-quality, architectural-grade asphalt shingles can withstand winds up to 130 mph, resist algae growth, and handle years of harsh sunlight.
Steel shingles do offer better performance against hail and fire, but they can dent under impact — especially from large hailstones. While these dents may be only cosmetic, it’s important to note that many insurance companies don’t cover hail dents on metal roofs unless there’s a full penetration or structural damage.
In addition, steel roofs can sometimes create more noise during heavy rain unless properly insulated. Asphalt shingles, by contrast, naturally absorb sound and provide quiet, reliable protection in all types of weather.
Energy Efficiency and Eco-Friendliness
Contrary to common belief, asphalt shingles can also be energy efficient. Many premium brands now feature “cool roof” technology, reflecting more sunlight and reducing indoor cooling costs.
Steel shingles are highly reflective and recyclable, but they often require extra insulation to prevent heat loss during colder months — offsetting some of their energy-saving benefits.
For most temperate climates, asphalt shingles offer the right balance of comfort and efficiency without the higher costs associated with metal roofing.
Why Asphalt Shingles Remain the Most Popular Choice
Affordability: Asphalt shingles offer unbeatable value for their price.
Aesthetic Variety: Available in a wide range of designs and colors.
Ease of Installation: Faster and simpler than metal roofing.
Quiet and Comfortable: Naturally absorbs sound during rain or hail.
Proven Performance: Trusted by homeowners for generations.
It’s no surprise that asphalt shingles continue to be Minnesota’s most preferred roofing material — they meet the practical needs of homeowners without breaking the bank.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. How long do asphalt shingles last compared to steel shingles?
Asphalt shingles typically last 20–30 years, while steel shingles can last longer. However, asphalt roofs often remain the most cost-effective choice for the average homeowner.
2. Are asphalt shingles good for all climates?
Yes. Modern asphalt shingles perform well in both hot and cold climates, with options designed for enhanced wind, algae, and UV resistance.
3. Do asphalt shingles require a lot of maintenance?
Not at all. Routine inspections and minor repairs are usually enough to keep them in top shape for decades.
4. Can asphalt shingles be recycled?
Yes. Many regions now offer asphalt shingle recycling programs that repurpose old roofing materials into road pavement.
5. Are steel shingles worth the extra cost?
They can be — but mostly for homeowners planning to stay in the same home for 40+ years. For most, asphalt shingles provide a faster ROI with similar protection.
6. Which roofing type adds more resale value?
A well-installed asphalt shingle roof adds strong curb appeal and can boost resale value. It’s a reliable, low-maintenance choice that buyers appreciate.
A Smart, Stylish, and Sensible Roofing Choice
While steel shingles have their strengths, asphalt shingles remain the go-to choice for most homeowners in 2026 — offering durability, affordability, and timeless beauty.
With the latest technology improving their performance and lifespan, asphalt shingles aren’t just the economical option — they’re a smart long-term investment that blends practicality with aesthetic appeal.
If you’re considering a roof replacement, choosing asphalt shingles gives you style, value, and peace of mind without the premium price tag.
Ready to See How Much a New Roof Will Cost?
Don’t guess — get real numbers tailored to your home.
Use our Free Roof Replacement Cost Calculator to instantly estimate your project cost based on your roof size, materials, and location.